"Pearl"
1. Pearl was given her name because of her great cost and she was her mother's only treasure, but at the end of the chapter Hester claimed that Pearl "art no Pearl of mine! (88)". Why does she believe or want to believe that Pearl is no child of hers?
2. What is the significance of the first thing Pearl noticing in her life the scarlet letter?
"The Governor's Hall"
1. Pearl is seen as being of demonic origin to the Puritans and the children of the Puritans. However, she is also described as an "angel of judgment--whose mission was to punish the sins of the rising generation (92)". Do you view her as a being of demonic origin or as an angel of judgment? Why?
2. At the end of the chapter, Pearl began to cry for a red rose upon seeing the rose-bushes. What does this symbolize? Do the rose-bushes relate to the wild rose-bushes discussed in the first chapter of the book?
Saturday, January 31, 2015
Friday, January 30, 2015
At the end of the chapter, Hester asks, "Why dost thou smile so at me?" Why do you think Roger Chillingworth is smiling at Hester in such a troubling time?
How does Roger feel about the incident between Hester and himself? Is he blaming himself? If so, why?
Chapter 5
Why does Hester feel so lonely? Is it due to the shame of what she did? The environment that she is surrounded by?
We see on page 77 that it is a form of "torture" when strangers state at the scarlet letter. Why is this torture to Hester?
Chapter 6
Compare and contrast Pearl and her mother. What similarities do you see in their current circumstances? Any differences?
On page 88, Pearl says, "I have no Heavenly Father!" What might this symbolize? How does it relate to Pearl's circumstances and her personality?
Chapter 7
Do you see any comparisons between Pearl and the scarlet letter? Where?
On page 93, Hester says, "Thou must gather thine own sunshine. I have none to give thee!" What does sunshine symbolize here?
How does Roger feel about the incident between Hester and himself? Is he blaming himself? If so, why?
Chapter 5
Why does Hester feel so lonely? Is it due to the shame of what she did? The environment that she is surrounded by?
We see on page 77 that it is a form of "torture" when strangers state at the scarlet letter. Why is this torture to Hester?
Chapter 6
Compare and contrast Pearl and her mother. What similarities do you see in their current circumstances? Any differences?
On page 88, Pearl says, "I have no Heavenly Father!" What might this symbolize? How does it relate to Pearl's circumstances and her personality?
Chapter 7
Do you see any comparisons between Pearl and the scarlet letter? Where?
On page 93, Hester says, "Thou must gather thine own sunshine. I have none to give thee!" What does sunshine symbolize here?
The Interview - The Governor's Hall Questions
The Interview
What does Robert Chillingworth ask of Hester and why?
When convincing Hester to drink his medicine, what does Robert Chillingworth say is a worse fate than death for Hester?
Hester at Her Needle
Why does Hester spend so much time making clothes for the poor?
What was the one thing that Hester never embroidered?
Pearl
There are a lot of comparisons in this chapter that link Pearl to evil and witchcraft. Do you think Hawthorne is trying to say she was born evil or she became evil because of how the society treated her?
Is Pearl truly evil, or is our perception of her influenced by Hester and the townspeople's fears?
The Governor's Hall
Is Pearl's dress used to highlight the contrasts between her and the Scarlet Letter or to show the similarities?
When Hester is in the Governor's Hall on p.95, she sees a reflection of herself in a polished breastplate, and her Scarlet Letter is blown into "exaggerated and gigantic proportions." What does this symbolize?
Discussion Questions Chapters 4-7
Chapter 4
1. Why doesn't Hester condemn Roger Chillingworth by revealing his name? Is there something in it for her if she doesn't reveal his name?
2. Chillingworth says, "from the moment when we came down the old church-steps together, a married pair, I might have beheld the bale-fire of that scarlet letter blazing at the end of our path." (67). Why did he say this? Does he claim that he should have seen this because of Hester or because of him?
Chapter 5
1. After Hester gets out of jail, she has the option to leave town and escape much of the shame that comes along with wearing a scarlet letter. She chooses not to leave because "the chain that bound her here was of iron links, and galling to her inmost soul, but never could be broken" (72). Why is this "chain" so strong? Does it have anything to do with the father of her child and his location?
2. Does Hester wish the other sinners in the Puritan society were publicly shamed for their sins?
Chapter 6
1. At the beginning of the chapter, the author brings the reader closer by starting off with "we". Why does Hawthorne choose this moment to pull the reader in another step?
2. Pearl is described as "her mother's only treasure" (80). Does this suggest that Hester is happy that Pearl was born?
Chapter 7
1. When Hester looks in the suit of armor and sees that the scarlet letter makes up most of the reflection, why is she so horrified by this? Is this how other people see her (figuratively)?
2. To go to the Governor's Mansion, Hester puts Pearl in a crimson tunic. Did Hester do this to connect their fates? Was she unaware of the connection between her letter and the tunic?
1. Why doesn't Hester condemn Roger Chillingworth by revealing his name? Is there something in it for her if she doesn't reveal his name?
2. Chillingworth says, "from the moment when we came down the old church-steps together, a married pair, I might have beheld the bale-fire of that scarlet letter blazing at the end of our path." (67). Why did he say this? Does he claim that he should have seen this because of Hester or because of him?
Chapter 5
1. After Hester gets out of jail, she has the option to leave town and escape much of the shame that comes along with wearing a scarlet letter. She chooses not to leave because "the chain that bound her here was of iron links, and galling to her inmost soul, but never could be broken" (72). Why is this "chain" so strong? Does it have anything to do with the father of her child and his location?
2. Does Hester wish the other sinners in the Puritan society were publicly shamed for their sins?
Chapter 6
1. At the beginning of the chapter, the author brings the reader closer by starting off with "we". Why does Hawthorne choose this moment to pull the reader in another step?
2. Pearl is described as "her mother's only treasure" (80). Does this suggest that Hester is happy that Pearl was born?
Chapter 7
1. When Hester looks in the suit of armor and sees that the scarlet letter makes up most of the reflection, why is she so horrified by this? Is this how other people see her (figuratively)?
2. To go to the Governor's Mansion, Hester puts Pearl in a crimson tunic. Did Hester do this to connect their fates? Was she unaware of the connection between her letter and the tunic?
The Interview and Hester at Her Needle Questions
"The Interview"
1. Chillingworth claimed his purpose in life was to live and die unknown. Do you think he believes this is simply his destiny or his own punishment for wronging Hester?
2. What did Hester sentence herself to when she took the oath? Do you think she will keep the oath?
"Hester at Her Needle"
1. After reading about the scarlet letter's ability to give Hester knowledge of a hidden sin in other people's hearts, what does the scarlet letter represent? Has your representation of it changed since the beginning of the book after reading this chapter?
2. Despite the society and its people's attempts to single out Hester and treat her poorly for her sins, she still manages to keep her patience and even give clothes that she made to those less miserable than her. What does this tell you about her character?
1. Chillingworth claimed his purpose in life was to live and die unknown. Do you think he believes this is simply his destiny or his own punishment for wronging Hester?
2. What did Hester sentence herself to when she took the oath? Do you think she will keep the oath?
"Hester at Her Needle"
1. After reading about the scarlet letter's ability to give Hester knowledge of a hidden sin in other people's hearts, what does the scarlet letter represent? Has your representation of it changed since the beginning of the book after reading this chapter?
2. Despite the society and its people's attempts to single out Hester and treat her poorly for her sins, she still manages to keep her patience and even give clothes that she made to those less miserable than her. What does this tell you about her character?
4-7 discussion questions
The Interview:
- Who would you rather be? Hester, who was publicly shamed, or Roger, the husband whose life was ruined by Hester, the wife who never even loved him.
- What is stopping Hester from revealing that Roger is her wife and ruining his reputation?
Hester at the needle
- Is the author’s goal in this chapter to make us sympathize of for Hester by tellin us how she will be used as a living example of what not to do, never being able to remove the scarlet letter from her chest and the shame that comes with it?
- When Hawthorne writes “There dwelt, there trode the feet of one with whom she deemed herself connected in a union, that, unrecognized on earth, would bring them together before the bar of final judgement, and make that their marriage-altar, for a join futurity of endless retribution”(pg. 72), do you think he is saying that marriage, like sin, both are determined by godly beings, and both have “endless retribution[s]”?
Pearl
- Why does Hawthorne decide to break the 4th wall again when he says “We have as yet hardly spoken of the infant”, referring the Pearl?
- Do you think that Pearl was made simply to act as a foil to Hester
The governer's hall
1. Can Hester ever truly love Pearl since she is both the only person that will accept her and a cruel reminder of how she came to be?
2. When Hester says "Thou must gather thine own sunshine. I have none to give thee!", was she saying that she has no happiness to offer Pearl due to her sins, that Pearl needs to find her own hapiness?
Thursday, January 29, 2015
Questions for Chapters 4-7
Chapter 4: The Interview
- In this chapter she seems to care for Pearl and her not getting killed, a huge difference from when she was using her shame of the baby to hide her shame of the letter. Why does she care now?
- What is Hawthorne's view on youth/old age? He describes youth/decay as an "unnatural relationship" (67). Does this mean that the older, the worse? If perhaps, then why have the youth of Pearl whose practically the devil?
Chapter 5: Hester at Her Needle
- What was Hawthorne's opinion on this hypocritical society?
- If "outward guise of purity was but a lie" (78) is anybody really pure? Is he insinuating that Hestor is pure because she doesn't lie about her impurity... except by admitting she's not pure it makes her, well, not pure. Does this mean no one is pure in Hawthorne's eyes?
Chapter 6: Pearl
- Pearl, when Hestor doubted her humanity (what kind of a mother does that?), "would turn her vivid and beautiful little face upon her mother, smile with sprite-like intelligence, and resume her play" (86). She also seems "incapable and unintelligent of human sorrow" (83) yet "sobs[s] out her love for her mother... intent on proving that she had a heart by breaking it" (83). Does she really care and is she really capable of these emotions or are these all just feigned emotions that a psycho/sociopath would fake in order to manipulate Hestor?
- Granted this is only by association and jumping to conclusions on exactly what sun means, but if you assume sunshine is a good thing why is Pearl often associated with words that evokes the feeling of the sun?
Chapter 7: The Governor's Hall
- What is the actual symbolism of the sun?
- Looking on page 95 with the mirror and page 87 when Hestor is looking into her daughters eye, what can be said about reflection?
Chapters 4-7 Questions
#1 Why does Hester still refuse to tell Roger the father of her baby? Is it out of loyalty or something else?
#2 Why did Roger return after wronging Hester?
#1 If Hester can leave the town and escape her shame, why would she decide to stay?
#2 How can the scarlet letter bring Hester daily torture and relief at the same time? Does this change what it symbolizes?
#1 Does Hester love her child even though she appears to be afraid of her?
#2 Will Hester's paranoia about her child's peculiar expressions affect their relationship?
#1 What does sunshine symbolize? "Thou must gather thine own sunshine. I have non to give thee!" (p. 93)
#2 Can we narrow down the meaning of the rosebush after hearing Pearl cry out for a rose?
Chapters 4-7 Discussion Questions
Discussion Questions:
The Interview:
1) Do you think their is any signifigance that Hester's husband, a man that has caused her so much pain, is also Hester's doctor? Does this relate to the theme of "Misogyny is Good", and if so how? Or, is this just Hawthorne trying to be satirical?
2) Why does Roger Chillenworth blame himself for his wife leaving him, and what does this reveal of his character?
Hester at Her Needle:
1) The title "Hester at Her Needle" evokes the three fates from ancient greek mythology, suggesting that Hester is in control of her own destiny. To what extent to you agree or disagree with this statement?
2) How does the theme that "Misogyny is Good" come up in needlework?
The Pearl:
1) A pearl, an object of great beauty, has crude beginnings, developing inside of an oyster (an object of lesser attraction). What does this suggest the future of Hester's daughter holds, and how does this play into the themes of the novel?
2) How do Pearl and Hester differ and resemble each other?
The Governor's Hall:
1) Why is Pearl so disobedient?
2) Do you think Pearl will become as deeply branded by the scarlet letter as her mother? Will Hester's actions affect herself more, or her daughter?
The Interview:
1) Do you think their is any signifigance that Hester's husband, a man that has caused her so much pain, is also Hester's doctor? Does this relate to the theme of "Misogyny is Good", and if so how? Or, is this just Hawthorne trying to be satirical?
2) Why does Roger Chillenworth blame himself for his wife leaving him, and what does this reveal of his character?
Hester at Her Needle:
1) The title "Hester at Her Needle" evokes the three fates from ancient greek mythology, suggesting that Hester is in control of her own destiny. To what extent to you agree or disagree with this statement?
2) How does the theme that "Misogyny is Good" come up in needlework?
The Pearl:
1) A pearl, an object of great beauty, has crude beginnings, developing inside of an oyster (an object of lesser attraction). What does this suggest the future of Hester's daughter holds, and how does this play into the themes of the novel?
2) How do Pearl and Hester differ and resemble each other?
The Governor's Hall:
1) Why is Pearl so disobedient?
2) Do you think Pearl will become as deeply branded by the scarlet letter as her mother? Will Hester's actions affect herself more, or her daughter?
Discussion Questions Ch. 4-7
The Interview
- Is Roger Chillingworth justified in believe it's his fault that Hester Prynne was compelled to cheat on him?
- Why would Hester marry Roger if she "...felt no love, nor feigned any"?
Hester at her Needle
- Does the description of the children calling Hester names they don't understand support the idea that hate is taught, and not natural?
- Hesters seems to know that she's not alone in sinning. Could this be foreshadowing a bond with another sinner?
Pearl
- Does Pearl asking Hester where she comes from signifiy that Hester is lying to herself about the event that placed her under her current circumstances?
- Could the name Pearl signify she is Hester's reward for the pain she's been through (i.e. the pearl built around the irritating grain of sand)?
The Governor's Hall
- Could the contrast of light and dark used to describe Pearl be related to Hester thinking she is both a reward and a demon?
- Does Hester's refusal to give Pearl 'sunshine' represent her lack of joy and happiness?
- Is Roger Chillingworth justified in believe it's his fault that Hester Prynne was compelled to cheat on him?
- Why would Hester marry Roger if she "...felt no love, nor feigned any"?
Hester at her Needle
- Does the description of the children calling Hester names they don't understand support the idea that hate is taught, and not natural?
- Hesters seems to know that she's not alone in sinning. Could this be foreshadowing a bond with another sinner?
Pearl
- Does Pearl asking Hester where she comes from signifiy that Hester is lying to herself about the event that placed her under her current circumstances?
- Could the name Pearl signify she is Hester's reward for the pain she's been through (i.e. the pearl built around the irritating grain of sand)?
The Governor's Hall
- Could the contrast of light and dark used to describe Pearl be related to Hester thinking she is both a reward and a demon?
- Does Hester's refusal to give Pearl 'sunshine' represent her lack of joy and happiness?
Wednesday, January 28, 2015
Questions
The Interview
- Why does Roger Chillingworth show Hester mercy, after she cheated on him and had a baby
- Why is Hester still refusing to divulge the name of her baby's father? Is she protecting him? If so, why?
- Why does Hester not want to leave town, where she can start over new?
- How does Hester show that she feels guilty for what she did?
- Does Pearl remind Hester of her sin? How does Hester feel towards her child?
- Pearl is wise beyond her years, in that she knew she had no 'heavenly-father,' what is she supposed to represent?
- Does Hester see Pearl as a better version of herself? Or an additional burden?
- Hester dresses Pearl in colors similar to the colors on the scarlet letter. Is Hester trying to make a point to Pearl that she is an abomination, like herself?
Discussion Questions
The Interview
1. Why does Hawthorne include long passages about Roger wanting vengeance? Is he trying to express a common theme or message?
2. Why does Hester still refuse to say who the father of the baby is? Is it an act of defiance, or something deeper?
Hester at her Needle
1. How is romanticism used in this chapter?
2. In what way is Hester a martyr?
Pearl
1. What similarities can be drawn between Pearl and the scarlet letter?
2. Why is Pearl's intelligence emphasized through out the chapter?
The Governor's Hall
1. Why does Hester dress Pearl in clothing similar to the scarlet letter?
2. What does Hester mean when she says to Pearl, "Thou must gather thine own sunshine. I have none to give thee!" (93)
1. Why does Hawthorne include long passages about Roger wanting vengeance? Is he trying to express a common theme or message?
2. Why does Hester still refuse to say who the father of the baby is? Is it an act of defiance, or something deeper?
Hester at her Needle
1. How is romanticism used in this chapter?
2. In what way is Hester a martyr?
Pearl
1. What similarities can be drawn between Pearl and the scarlet letter?
2. Why is Pearl's intelligence emphasized through out the chapter?
The Governor's Hall
1. Why does Hester dress Pearl in clothing similar to the scarlet letter?
2. What does Hester mean when she says to Pearl, "Thou must gather thine own sunshine. I have none to give thee!" (93)
Discussion Questions: The Interview, Hester at Her Needle, Pearl, The Governor's Hall
The Interview:
1. When Chillingworth says, "No matter whether of love or hate, no matter whether of right or wrong! Thou and thine, Hester Prynne, belong to me. My home is where thou art"(68), does that show that Chillingworth still loves Hester, or something else?
2. Why does Hester continue to refuse to tell who the father of the baby is, even to a man she knows will not tell, Chillingworth, because he does not want to be known as husband of a faithless woman?
Hester at Her Needle:
1. Why does Hester seem to feel even more alone when she thinks that there are other people in the Puritan society who have sinned as well, even if they have not been publicly shamed for it?
2. Why does Hester feel that she should stay in the town to receive the shame and punishment of her sin when she could leave the town and move on?
Pearl:
1. Why is Hester afraid of Pearl?
2. Was Pearl born knowing she is an outcast because she was a product of sin, or does she know her place in society because she was raised that way by Hester? (Nurture vs. Nature)
The Governor's Hall:
1. If Hester already feels isolated walking down the streets with a Scarlet Letter on her chest, why does she clothe her daughter also in a crimson dress and gold thread to walk to the Governor's Hall?
2. Why does Hester continue to doubt that Pearl is her child?
1. When Chillingworth says, "No matter whether of love or hate, no matter whether of right or wrong! Thou and thine, Hester Prynne, belong to me. My home is where thou art"(68), does that show that Chillingworth still loves Hester, or something else?
2. Why does Hester continue to refuse to tell who the father of the baby is, even to a man she knows will not tell, Chillingworth, because he does not want to be known as husband of a faithless woman?
Hester at Her Needle:
1. Why does Hester seem to feel even more alone when she thinks that there are other people in the Puritan society who have sinned as well, even if they have not been publicly shamed for it?
2. Why does Hester feel that she should stay in the town to receive the shame and punishment of her sin when she could leave the town and move on?
Pearl:
1. Why is Hester afraid of Pearl?
2. Was Pearl born knowing she is an outcast because she was a product of sin, or does she know her place in society because she was raised that way by Hester? (Nurture vs. Nature)
The Governor's Hall:
1. If Hester already feels isolated walking down the streets with a Scarlet Letter on her chest, why does she clothe her daughter also in a crimson dress and gold thread to walk to the Governor's Hall?
2. Why does Hester continue to doubt that Pearl is her child?
Discussion Questions
The Interview
1. Since Hester did not seem bothered by the shame, and punishment forced upon her in the earlier chapters, why do you think she suddenly feels so depressed when the doctor comes to visit her? Does he have any influence on her behavior?
2. Why do you that Robert is still motivated to identify the baby's father instead of leaving Hester, regardless of knowing that she cheated on him? Do you think he has an alterior motive?
Hester At Her Needle
1. On page 71, do you think the author exagerated the burden Hester would carry if she refused to reveal the father's name as a warning to the other women? Or is it more of a warning to Hester of her future misery?
2. Does Hester hope that she may have a future at a real relationship with her child's father, or is it all a delusion to her? Is that why she "looked the idea in the face, and hastened to bar it in its dungeon"(72)?
Pearl
1. Do you think Hester feels guilty that she brought Pearl into this world under unfavorable circumstances? Or does she feel sorry for the child to have to bear the sin that Hester brought into the family?
2. How does Pearl's disassociation with society, especially interacting with other children, affect her behavior?
The Governor's Hall
1. Is Hester's action to ask Governor Bellingham for assistance with her custody issues of Pearl justified with the fact that "an unequal match between the public, on the one side, and a lonely women"(91) would result in an unfair decision?
2. Do you think that Pearl understands the shame, and torture forced upon Hester, so she feels obligated to protect her mother, as she did on page 92, when she rebelled against the other children's harsh actions?
1. Since Hester did not seem bothered by the shame, and punishment forced upon her in the earlier chapters, why do you think she suddenly feels so depressed when the doctor comes to visit her? Does he have any influence on her behavior?
2. Why do you that Robert is still motivated to identify the baby's father instead of leaving Hester, regardless of knowing that she cheated on him? Do you think he has an alterior motive?
Hester At Her Needle
1. On page 71, do you think the author exagerated the burden Hester would carry if she refused to reveal the father's name as a warning to the other women? Or is it more of a warning to Hester of her future misery?
2. Does Hester hope that she may have a future at a real relationship with her child's father, or is it all a delusion to her? Is that why she "looked the idea in the face, and hastened to bar it in its dungeon"(72)?
Pearl
1. Do you think Hester feels guilty that she brought Pearl into this world under unfavorable circumstances? Or does she feel sorry for the child to have to bear the sin that Hester brought into the family?
2. How does Pearl's disassociation with society, especially interacting with other children, affect her behavior?
The Governor's Hall
1. Is Hester's action to ask Governor Bellingham for assistance with her custody issues of Pearl justified with the fact that "an unequal match between the public, on the one side, and a lonely women"(91) would result in an unfair decision?
2. Do you think that Pearl understands the shame, and torture forced upon Hester, so she feels obligated to protect her mother, as she did on page 92, when she rebelled against the other children's harsh actions?
Discussion questions
Pearl:
It says Pearl was "a born outcast of the infantile world.... Nothing was more remarkable than the instinct, as it seemed, with which the child comprehended her loneliness,"(85). Because of the situation Pearl was born into, how will this impact her? Will it make her hate society? Can you predict any repercussions that might happen due to how much she will probably loathe the Puritan community
Do you think Parents have a great deal of influence on their children and how they act or think? If so, how can that connect to the book and specifically this chapter?
Overall, what do you think Hester thinks about her child? Would she say Pearl is a blessing or a curse? If you think both, how so and what message do you think Hawthorn is trying to send?
The Govern's Hall
Pearl cries for a red rose. Do this signify anything? How are flowers symbolic to the book in all the chapters we have read so far?
It says Hester dresses Pearl in the same colors as her scarlet letter. Why does she do this?
Pearl and The Governor's Hall Questions
Pearl
1. Does Pearl restrain from making friends with any of the other children by her own choice, or by her mother's unintentional influence?
2. Pearl is often compared to mystical beings, such as an "airy sprite" or a "demon offspring". Why does Hester seem to struggle between deciding which one she is?
The Governor's Hall
1. Hester does not stop Pearl from violently running after the children in the town; does this suggest that she would rather Pearl be taken from her as a demon-child than as an orphan of an unfit mother?
2. Does the exaggerated reflection of Hester's scarlet letter symbolize the townspeople's view of Hester or Hester's view of herself?
1. Does Pearl restrain from making friends with any of the other children by her own choice, or by her mother's unintentional influence?
2. Pearl is often compared to mystical beings, such as an "airy sprite" or a "demon offspring". Why does Hester seem to struggle between deciding which one she is?
The Governor's Hall
1. Hester does not stop Pearl from violently running after the children in the town; does this suggest that she would rather Pearl be taken from her as a demon-child than as an orphan of an unfit mother?
2. Does the exaggerated reflection of Hester's scarlet letter symbolize the townspeople's view of Hester or Hester's view of herself?
Discussion Questions: Pearl and The Governor's Hall
Pearl:
- Does Hester Prynne believe that her daughter, Pearl, is her punishment?
- Why does Hester only feel safe when her daughter is sleeping or why is she afraid when her daughter is awake?
The Governor's Hall
- Is Pearl seen as another Scarlet Letter, a punishment, that Hester Prynne has to "wear" or have with her at all times?
- Hester Prynne says, "Thou must gather thine own sunshine. I have no to give thee!" Is there another meaning to this statement besides the literal?
Discussion Questions (Pearl + The Governors Hall)
Pearl
Why did Pearl not make any acquaintances or friends as a
child?
Is the fact that the town people think Pearl “was a demon
offspring” (89) affecting her as a child? Will it affect her as she grows
older?
The Governors Hall
Why does Hester dress Pearl in the same colors as her
scarlet letter?
Why does Hester tell Pearl, “Thou must gather thine own sunshine.
I have non to give thee?” (93) What is the significance of sunlight in this scene?
The Prison Door - The Recognition Hester Discussion Questions
Hester Prynne
-What do the other women think of Hester's sentence? Why?
-Who seemed to be the one woman in the crowd who gave Hester sympathy?
-What kind of childhood did Hester have?
-How does Hester act towards her baby?
-What do the other women think of Hester's sentence? Why?
-Who seemed to be the one woman in the crowd who gave Hester sympathy?
-What kind of childhood did Hester have?
-How does Hester act towards her baby?
Discussion Questions
The Interview
1) If Hester claims to have never loved "Roger Chillingworth," why did they marry?
2) If Chillingworth is so ashamed of Hester, why does he insist on living in the same town? He could easily move far away and begin his life again.
3) What other reasons could Chillingworth have for keeping his true identity secret other than to avoid the shame of being associated with Hester? Why does he repeatedly smile sinisterly at Hester? I think that Roger Chillingworth isn't as pure as he seems.
Hester at Her Needle
1)If Hester is free to move anywhere, to a place where she wouldn't be constantly ridiculed, why doesn't she go? Does she hope to maintain a relationship with the father of her child? If you were Hester, would you stay or leave?
2)How is Hester's needlework ironic?
Pearl
1)What does Hawthorne mean when he writes "in this one child there were many children"?
2)How does Hester feel about Pearl? She seems like both a torment and a treasure for Hester.
The Governor's Hall
1)If Pearl was raised by someone other than Hester, would she still be treated as an outcast?
2)The material from which the governor's house is made glitters, as does the armor within. What does light represent in this chapter?
1) If Hester claims to have never loved "Roger Chillingworth," why did they marry?
2) If Chillingworth is so ashamed of Hester, why does he insist on living in the same town? He could easily move far away and begin his life again.
3) What other reasons could Chillingworth have for keeping his true identity secret other than to avoid the shame of being associated with Hester? Why does he repeatedly smile sinisterly at Hester? I think that Roger Chillingworth isn't as pure as he seems.
Hester at Her Needle
1)If Hester is free to move anywhere, to a place where she wouldn't be constantly ridiculed, why doesn't she go? Does she hope to maintain a relationship with the father of her child? If you were Hester, would you stay or leave?
2)How is Hester's needlework ironic?
Pearl
1)What does Hawthorne mean when he writes "in this one child there were many children"?
2)How does Hester feel about Pearl? She seems like both a torment and a treasure for Hester.
The Governor's Hall
1)If Pearl was raised by someone other than Hester, would she still be treated as an outcast?
2)The material from which the governor's house is made glitters, as does the armor within. What does light represent in this chapter?
Tuesday, January 27, 2015
"Market Place" and "Recognition" Questions
1)At the very beginning of the novel, Hawthorne describes a rosebush in front of the prison, breaks the fourth wall, and offers the reader a rose. Why does he do this? What does the rose/rosebush symbolize?
2)The women gossiping about Hester are described as being made of "a coarser fibre ... than ... their fair descendants" (55). The reason is that "throughout the chain of ancestry, every successive mother has transmitted to her child a fainter bloom, a more delicate and briefer beauty, and a slighter physical frame, if not a character of less force and solidity, than her own (55). What does this mean? How does this relate to the rest of the novel?
3)Is Hester's decision not to reveal the father of her child a measure to protect the father, or make him bear his guilt internally? Is there another motive?
2)The women gossiping about Hester are described as being made of "a coarser fibre ... than ... their fair descendants" (55). The reason is that "throughout the chain of ancestry, every successive mother has transmitted to her child a fainter bloom, a more delicate and briefer beauty, and a slighter physical frame, if not a character of less force and solidity, than her own (55). What does this mean? How does this relate to the rest of the novel?
3)Is Hester's decision not to reveal the father of her child a measure to protect the father, or make him bear his guilt internally? Is there another motive?
Discussion Questions ( Ch. 4-7)
The Interview:
1) On pg. 67, Hester says, "I was frank with thee. I felt no love, nor feigned any." Does Hester believe that it was okay for her to have an affair with someone else on the pretense that her husband knew she didn't love him?
2) "Without further expostulation or delay, Hester Prynne drained the cup.." (pg. 66) How could Hester really believe that her husband would poison her? Does she really believe he would essentially murder her? If so, why?
Hester at her Needle:
1) In the middle of the first passage on pg. 71, the narrator talks about Hester Prynne being the "figure, the body, the reality of sin." and embodying the "image of women's frailty and sinful passion." Why does Hawthorne place this passage in the novel? What is he saying about a woman's image during this time period?
2) "But there is a fatality, a feeling so irresistible and inevitable... compels human beings to linger around...the spot where some great... has given color to their lifetime; and still the more irresistibly, the darker tinge that saddens it." (pg.71) It almost feels like the narrator is saying that Hester Prynne purposely had an affair, to add drama or something of interest into her life. Is this what Hawthorne intended? If so, what are other pieces of evidence?
3) According to the fairytale of sleeping beauty, princess Aurora was bewitched by Maleficient to die on her 16th birthday. When she touched the poisonous needle, she fell into a everlasting sleep, only to be awoken by true love's first kiss. Due to the title of this chapter, are there any parallels between this fairytale and the story of the Scarlet Letter? If so, how do these two stories connect?
Pearl
1) What is the symbolism of Pearl touching the scarlet letter on pg. 87?
2) "But she said it with a hesitation that did not escape the acuteness of the child." pg. 88. What is the cause for Hester's hesitation before she replied to pearl?
The Governor's Hall
1) On pg. 96, Hester tells Pearl to not cry infront of the Governor and his gentlemen. Why does Hester not want to show the males in the novel any signs of weakness?
2) What does Hester mean when she says, "Thou must gather thine own sunshine. I have none to give thee!" pg. 93, to her daughter Pearl? What does sunshine symbolize in this case?
2)
The Prison Door-The Recognition Hester Questions
#1 Is Hester ashamed of her sin? Explain.
#2 How does Hester's appearance contribute to the way the town's women think of her?
#3 What are Hester's feelings towards the man with the uneven shoulders?
#4 Why doe Hester refuse to say the name of her baby's father?
Reverend Dimmesdale Questions
1. While Mr. Wilson was describing Reverend Dimmesdale to Hester Prynne, he says, "Knowing your natural temper better than I, he [Dimmesdale] could the better judge what arguments to use... (59)". How would Dimmesdale know her "natural temper" better than him? Did they know each other before? Is that why this chapter is called "The Recognition"?
2. Dimmesdale, according to Reverend Wilson, believes it is "wronging the very nature of woman to force her to lay open her heart's secrets in such broad daylight, and in presence of so great a multidude (59)". Why does he believe it is wrong, when everyone else believes it is right? Are his morals correct?
3. What was the significance of Dimmesdale's powerful voice and "the feeling that is so evidently manifested, rather than the direct purport of the words, caused it to vibrate within all hearts, and brought the listeners into one accord of sympathy (61)"?
2. Dimmesdale, according to Reverend Wilson, believes it is "wronging the very nature of woman to force her to lay open her heart's secrets in such broad daylight, and in presence of so great a multidude (59)". Why does he believe it is wrong, when everyone else believes it is right? Are his morals correct?
3. What was the significance of Dimmesdale's powerful voice and "the feeling that is so evidently manifested, rather than the direct purport of the words, caused it to vibrate within all hearts, and brought the listeners into one accord of sympathy (61)"?
Questions on 'Pearl' and 'The Governor's Hall'
Pearl
1. What similarities does Pearl share with Hester?
2. How does Hester's crime both help and detract from the rest of the town?
3. The Scarlet letter and, Pearl, because she reminds her of the letter, are both negative aspects of Hester's life. Does she have any positive aspects?
The Governor's Hall
1. Why does Hawthorne consistently make references to flowers?
2. How does the way the community wants to deal with Pearl resemble the Witch Hunts? What does this say about Puritan society?
1. What similarities does Pearl share with Hester?
2. How does Hester's crime both help and detract from the rest of the town?
3. The Scarlet letter and, Pearl, because she reminds her of the letter, are both negative aspects of Hester's life. Does she have any positive aspects?
The Governor's Hall
1. Why does Hawthorne consistently make references to flowers?
2. How does the way the community wants to deal with Pearl resemble the Witch Hunts? What does this say about Puritan society?
Discussion Questions 'Pearl' and 'The Governor's Hall'
'Pearl'
1.) Why does Hester appear to be afraid of Pearl and 'never [feel] a moment's safety' when Pearl is awake? (Hawthorne 87)
2.) When Hester asks Pearl who sent her here, Pearl responds saying 'Tell me'.Is this Pearl asking who her father is? (pages 88-89) Will Hester reveal to Pearl who her father is? Or will she keep it a secret even to her child?
'The Governor's Hall'
1.) What does Hester think of people taking Pearl from her? Will she do anything to stop them if they do?
2.)Why is it that Pearl 'attacks' the people who taunt her and Hester? Is Hester proud of her for doing this or does she simply not care? Hester shows no signs of disapproval/approval when Pearl does this, so what is her opinion on the matter?
1.) Why does Hester appear to be afraid of Pearl and 'never [feel] a moment's safety' when Pearl is awake? (Hawthorne 87)
2.) When Hester asks Pearl who sent her here, Pearl responds saying 'Tell me'.Is this Pearl asking who her father is? (pages 88-89) Will Hester reveal to Pearl who her father is? Or will she keep it a secret even to her child?
'The Governor's Hall'
1.) What does Hester think of people taking Pearl from her? Will she do anything to stop them if they do?
2.)Why is it that Pearl 'attacks' the people who taunt her and Hester? Is Hester proud of her for doing this or does she simply not care? Hester shows no signs of disapproval/approval when Pearl does this, so what is her opinion on the matter?
Questions from Prison-Door - Marketplace
Character: The Stranger in the Crowd
1. Does the man question Hester Prynne's situation just for show, or are his inquiries genuine?
2. Does his deformity, though not specified as either on the right or left, link him to the man in Hester's memories?
3. The town seems to think Hester's husband drowned at sea. Does the stranger's tale of misfortunes on land and sea, as well as Hester's dread of talking to him, suggest that he might be her husband?
1. Does the man question Hester Prynne's situation just for show, or are his inquiries genuine?
2. Does his deformity, though not specified as either on the right or left, link him to the man in Hester's memories?
3. The town seems to think Hester's husband drowned at sea. Does the stranger's tale of misfortunes on land and sea, as well as Hester's dread of talking to him, suggest that he might be her husband?
Discussion questions
1. Do you think that Hawthorne is trying to criticize religious societies?
2. Do you think Dimmsdale has what it takes to be a ruthless clergy who must punish all who sin?
3. Does Dimmsdale respect Hester?
2. Do you think Dimmsdale has what it takes to be a ruthless clergy who must punish all who sin?
3. Does Dimmsdale respect Hester?
Discussion Questions: Pearl and The Governor's Hall
Pearl
1. Is there an ulterior reason as to why Hester thinks the way she does about Pearl? (Maybe Pearl reminds her of the sin she committed.)
2. Does Hester believe that the birth of Pearl, as well as Pearl's special attributes are a punishment?
3. What was Hester afraid of? Why was she scared of pearl?
4. What did Pearl mean when she said she had no 'heavenly father'? How was she able to conclude that at such a young age?
The Governor's Hall
1. Why did Hester visit the Governor?
2. In what ways are Pearl and the Scarlet letter alike?
Discussion Questions
The Interview:
- What are possible results of an interaction or meeting between Chillingworth and the father of Hester Prynne's child?
- Does Chillingworth or Hester Prynne want to regain the same marital status or relationship as they had before?
Hester at the Needle:
- Has Hester completely lost faith as a result of this wrong doing?
- Will helping the poor and those with less help Hester relieve the shame that she feels for wearing the Scarlet Letter?
"Interview", "Hester at Her Needle", "Pearl" & "The Governor's Hall" Discussion Questions
"The Interview"
1. Why is Esther so afraid and unnerved by Roger Chillingworth?
2. Does Roger Chillingworth really love Esther? (68-69 refusing to reveal their relationship)
"Hester at Her Needle"
1. How have the binaries of light and dark changed for Esther?
2. Is Esther ashamed or comforted (or both) by her crime?
3. Is Esther's reluctance to stand up for herself or leave New England a sign of feminism?
4. Does Esther view her happiness as a sin?
"Pearl"
1. What was Hawthorne's purpose in the naming and description of Pearl (80-81) ?
2. Why does Pearl "seem intent on proving she has a heart, by breaking it" (83) ?
3. What is Hawthorne trying to ironize with the description of the Puritans as the "most intolerable brood that ever lived" (85) ?
"The Governor's Hall"
1. Why doesn't Hester do anything to stop the ridicule of Pearl, who always challenges her enemies?
2. What does Hawthorne mean when referring to the rationing of sunlight (93) ?
3. What are roses symbolic of? (in color, thorns, beauty, use, etc.)
1. Why is Esther so afraid and unnerved by Roger Chillingworth?
2. Does Roger Chillingworth really love Esther? (68-69 refusing to reveal their relationship)
"Hester at Her Needle"
1. How have the binaries of light and dark changed for Esther?
2. Is Esther ashamed or comforted (or both) by her crime?
3. Is Esther's reluctance to stand up for herself or leave New England a sign of feminism?
4. Does Esther view her happiness as a sin?
"Pearl"
1. What was Hawthorne's purpose in the naming and description of Pearl (80-81) ?
2. Why does Pearl "seem intent on proving she has a heart, by breaking it" (83) ?
3. What is Hawthorne trying to ironize with the description of the Puritans as the "most intolerable brood that ever lived" (85) ?
"The Governor's Hall"
1. Why doesn't Hester do anything to stop the ridicule of Pearl, who always challenges her enemies?
2. What does Hawthorne mean when referring to the rationing of sunlight (93) ?
3. What are roses symbolic of? (in color, thorns, beauty, use, etc.)
Monday, January 26, 2015
Discussion Questions: The Interview and Hester at Her Needle
The Interview
1. Why did Chillingworth decide to visit Hester? What were his motives?
2. Was Hester's affair some sort of revenge on Chillingworth for leaving her all by herself?
Hester at Her Needle
1. What did the narrator mean when they said vanity had 'chose to mortify itself'? How did that apply to Hester?
2. What sense did Scarlet attain for wearing the Scarlet Letter and why did she say it was the 'most awful' sense?
1. Why did Chillingworth decide to visit Hester? What were his motives?
2. Was Hester's affair some sort of revenge on Chillingworth for leaving her all by herself?
Hester at Her Needle
1. What did the narrator mean when they said vanity had 'chose to mortify itself'? How did that apply to Hester?
2. What sense did Scarlet attain for wearing the Scarlet Letter and why did she say it was the 'most awful' sense?
Sunday, January 25, 2015
Discussion Questions
The Interview
- Why does Hester not want the Father of her child to experience the same guilt and weight of sin that she is experiencing?
- What could Chillingworth's "other reasons"(65) for keeping his identity a secret be?
Hester at her Needle
- What about Pearl's attire has a "deeper meaning" (70)?
- Will Hester ever stand up for herself against the people of the town who stare and make bitter remarks? Or does she feel her shame too deeply?
Discussion Questions
The Interview
1. Why does Hester not drink the position Chillingworth has
made for her immediately? What might be going through her mind when she holds
the cup and “look[s] also at her slumbering child?
2. What does Hester feel towards Chillingworth and why does
she call him, “the Black Man that haunts the forest?” (69)
Hester at Her Needle
1. Why does Hester decide not to flee, and instead stay
alone in the cabin, regardless of her isolation and loneliness?
2. Do the harsh stairs and judgments of the other town
members impact Hester? How do the town members make Hester feel about her situation?
Does she feel guilt and believes she has sinned? Or is she okay with what she
has done?
Reverend Dimmesdale discussion questions
1. Why do you think Reverend Dimmesdale is being less harsh to Hester than the other men (Rev. Wilson and the Governor) when he is trying to make her admit the name of the father of her baby?
2. When Mr. Dimmesdale says, "Wondrous strength and generosity of a woman's heart! She will not speak!"(61), does this show that he believes that she is doing a good deed by refusing to speak? Why would he think this?
3. Why does "the responsibility of [Hester's] soul lie greatly with"(59) Mr. Dimmesdale? Do you think they have some preexisting relationship?
2. When Mr. Dimmesdale says, "Wondrous strength and generosity of a woman's heart! She will not speak!"(61), does this show that he believes that she is doing a good deed by refusing to speak? Why would he think this?
3. Why does "the responsibility of [Hester's] soul lie greatly with"(59) Mr. Dimmesdale? Do you think they have some preexisting relationship?
Stranger in the Crowd Questions
Discussion Question
1) Who is the Stranger in the Crowd? Hester's Secret Lover?
2) What is the Stranger in the Crowd telling Hester not to say when he shushes her?
3) Why do you think Hawthorne made the Stranger in the Crowd Native American? Is Hawthorne trying to depict both Hester and the Stranger in the Crowd as outsiders thus making them allies?
The Interview and Hester at Her Needle Questions
The Interview
1. Why is Hester so reluctant to trust Chillingworth? Do you think he can be trusted with her and the baby?
2. Chillingworth apologetically speaks about how both he and Hester "wronged each other". Do you think he plans on returning his marriage with her to its previous state (before she left for America)?
Hester at Her Needle
1. Despite being allowed to move away from her punishment and the town, Hester chose to stay behind because, "her sins,.. were the roots which she had struck into the soil." (71) What does Hester mean by this and what caused her to think this way?
2. Why does Hester continue to fuel the hypocrisy of the town by doing charity work or making fancy clothing for those who continuously insult her?
1. Why is Hester so reluctant to trust Chillingworth? Do you think he can be trusted with her and the baby?
2. Chillingworth apologetically speaks about how both he and Hester "wronged each other". Do you think he plans on returning his marriage with her to its previous state (before she left for America)?
Hester at Her Needle
1. Despite being allowed to move away from her punishment and the town, Hester chose to stay behind because, "her sins,.. were the roots which she had struck into the soil." (71) What does Hester mean by this and what caused her to think this way?
2. Why does Hester continue to fuel the hypocrisy of the town by doing charity work or making fancy clothing for those who continuously insult her?
Hestor Prynne Questions
1. Why is Hestor described with "a burning blush, and yet a haughty smile" (47)? This woman is a living opposition to herself. Why did Hawthorne write her like this?
2. Why is Hestor described as such an awful mother?
3. Why won't Hestor name her 'partner in crime?' Is it out of love? Fear? Anger? Guilt? Shame? Etc.
2. Why is Hestor described as such an awful mother?
3. Why won't Hestor name her 'partner in crime?' Is it out of love? Fear? Anger? Guilt? Shame? Etc.
Saturday, January 24, 2015
Reverend Arthur Dimmesdale Questions
1. After Reverend Arthur Dimmesdale tries to get Hester Prynne to say the name of her baby's father, he is surprised to find that she will not reveal the name. When he says, "Wondrous strength and generosity of a woman's heart" (61), is this a good thing? Does he agree with her decision?
2. The Reverend calls Hester Prynne "Hester." Does this mean that he is on a first name basis with her?
3. The Reverend's words "brought the listeners into one accord of sympathy" (61). Does he sympathize with Hester as well?
2. The Reverend calls Hester Prynne "Hester." Does this mean that he is on a first name basis with her?
3. The Reverend's words "brought the listeners into one accord of sympathy" (61). Does he sympathize with Hester as well?
Questions for Chapter 4-5
The Interview
1. Why is Chillingworth willing to help Hester and her child recover? What does he want to know?
2. What is it about him that scares Hester most of all, especially when he looks at the Scarlet Letter?
Hester at her Needle
1. Why does Hester think "There was nothing that made her feel as if she belonged to it" in reference to her town's society?
2. Towards the end of the chapter, Hester believes she is able to see, or at least sense, the sins committed by others. Do you think she does, and if so, why? What does this say about the nature of sinning? If you think this is a product of her imagination, does that mean she is slipping to madness over being outcast?
1. Why is Chillingworth willing to help Hester and her child recover? What does he want to know?
2. What is it about him that scares Hester most of all, especially when he looks at the Scarlet Letter?
Hester at her Needle
1. Why does Hester think "There was nothing that made her feel as if she belonged to it" in reference to her town's society?
2. Towards the end of the chapter, Hester believes she is able to see, or at least sense, the sins committed by others. Do you think she does, and if so, why? What does this say about the nature of sinning? If you think this is a product of her imagination, does that mean she is slipping to madness over being outcast?
Friday, January 23, 2015
Discussion Questions
"The Interview"
1.) Why does Chillingworth seek vengeance on the man Hester had an affair with? He says that he does not seek vengeance on Hester or the baby, but why the man? What would he do to the man if he ever found him?
2.) Hester has said "I have thought of death", does this show that Hester has had suicidal thoughts? And if so, does she want to die because she is ashamed of what she did or she just doesn't want to deal with the harassment of the rest of society?
"Hester at Her Needle"
1.) Why does Hester wear the 'plainest and most ascetic' clothing possible? Is this another type of punishment or penance she is inflicting upon herself?
2.)Does the house mentioned in detail on pages 72-73 symbolize Hester's situation? The house is removed from the rest of society and 'ought to be, concealed.'
1.) Why does Chillingworth seek vengeance on the man Hester had an affair with? He says that he does not seek vengeance on Hester or the baby, but why the man? What would he do to the man if he ever found him?
2.) Hester has said "I have thought of death", does this show that Hester has had suicidal thoughts? And if so, does she want to die because she is ashamed of what she did or she just doesn't want to deal with the harassment of the rest of society?
"Hester at Her Needle"
1.) Why does Hester wear the 'plainest and most ascetic' clothing possible? Is this another type of punishment or penance she is inflicting upon herself?
2.)Does the house mentioned in detail on pages 72-73 symbolize Hester's situation? The house is removed from the rest of society and 'ought to be, concealed.'
Discussion questions (Sasha)
Hester at her Needle:
1. Do you think Hester believes what she did was wrong? It says she will now be the "general symbol at which the preacher and moralist might point, and in which they might vivify and embody their images of women's frailty and sinful passion." (71). However, do you think she thinks she is the reality of a sin, or does she stand by what she did?
2. It says Hester grew to have a dread for children because they "had imbibed from their parents a vague idea of something horrible in this dreary woman." (76). Does this show the uniformity and strict ways of the Puritan society?
1. Do you think Hester believes what she did was wrong? It says she will now be the "general symbol at which the preacher and moralist might point, and in which they might vivify and embody their images of women's frailty and sinful passion." (71). However, do you think she thinks she is the reality of a sin, or does she stand by what she did?
2. It says Hester grew to have a dread for children because they "had imbibed from their parents a vague idea of something horrible in this dreary woman." (76). Does this show the uniformity and strict ways of the Puritan society?
Discussion questions (Sasha)
The Interview:
1. Do you believe Hester is 'ahead of her time'? She expresses that she "felt no love, nor feigned any," (67) when talking about her arranged marriage.
2. Where does the baby fall into all of this? Do you think people will feel bad that the baby was born into this situation and treat it well, or will they ignore the baby? Furthermore, do you think Hester is in a well enough state of mind to take care of the baby right now?
1. Do you believe Hester is 'ahead of her time'? She expresses that she "felt no love, nor feigned any," (67) when talking about her arranged marriage.
2. Where does the baby fall into all of this? Do you think people will feel bad that the baby was born into this situation and treat it well, or will they ignore the baby? Furthermore, do you think Hester is in a well enough state of mind to take care of the baby right now?
1. Why do the generation of women in the town get more and more gentle and delicate as years pass by?
2. Why does Hawthorne portray the women with "broad shoulders" and "ruddy cheeks" when Hester Prynne is portrayed as this gorgeous young women?
3. What do the women say about Hester Prynne that gives the reader a negative view on her? Why do they say this?
Thursday, January 22, 2015
Hester Prynne Questions
- Why does Hester search for the approval of everyone in the crowd, when she is fulfilling her punishment for adultery?
- Why wouldn't Hester want to expose the father of her baby, and make him suffer the same as she does?
- What is the symbolism behind the scarlet letter 'A' that Hester tried so hard to make presentable, yet when people see it, it only divides her even more?
Stranger in the Crowd Questions
- Why does this stranger want to know who the father of Hester's child is so badly? Why does he want to reveal his identity?
- Why is this stranger attempting to conceal his identity from Hester and the other people in town?
- Hester does not seem to be afraid of many things, so why is she afraid of meeting this stranger alone?
Reverend Arthur Dimmesdale
- What is the previous relationship between Reverend Arthur Dimmesdale and Hester Prynne, if any?
- What is Reverend Dimmesdale's opinion about Hester Prynne?
- What does he mean when he says, "Wondrous strength and generosity of a woman's heart! She will not speak!" (p.61)
Stranger In the Crowd Questions
1. Who is the stranger in the crowd, and does Hester Pryyne seem to have a positive or negative view on his arrival?
2. Why does the stranger wish to have his identity remain a secret to those around him or why did the author choose to keep him unnamed?
3. Hester clearly recognized the stranger from even the smallest details; what significance do you think he has on her past?
2. Why does the stranger wish to have his identity remain a secret to those around him or why did the author choose to keep him unnamed?
3. Hester clearly recognized the stranger from even the smallest details; what significance do you think he has on her past?
Hester Prynne questions by Sasha
1. We first see Hester Prynne on page 47 when she is coming out of jail. She "repelled him, by an action marked with natural dignity and force of character, and stepped into the open air, as if by her own free-will." (47). Do you think this independent and self determined nature will affect her actions later on in the book? How do you think it impacted her past?
2. What is the importance of the A she is wearing on her chest? It says the A is "greatly beyond what was allowed by the sumptuary regulations of the colony" (47), does this speak to her character? Her past (like her background story)??
3. While everyone was expecting Hester Prynne to come out of prison looking poor and disheveled, she ends up coming out beautiful and in a fancy dress. Is her fancy outfit simply disguising her true feelings? What is the importance of this and what do you think is going on in her head at that moment?
4. What does this person mean why he says: "Do not let her hear you! Not a stitch in that embroidered letter, but she has felt it in her heart." (49)?
2. What is the importance of the A she is wearing on her chest? It says the A is "greatly beyond what was allowed by the sumptuary regulations of the colony" (47), does this speak to her character? Her past (like her background story)??
3. While everyone was expecting Hester Prynne to come out of prison looking poor and disheveled, she ends up coming out beautiful and in a fancy dress. Is her fancy outfit simply disguising her true feelings? What is the importance of this and what do you think is going on in her head at that moment?
4. What does this person mean why he says: "Do not let her hear you! Not a stitch in that embroidered letter, but she has felt it in her heart." (49)?
Stranger in the Crowd Questions
1. Why is the stranger in both "civilized" and Indian garb? Is there a deeper significance to his outfit?
2. Why does the stranger motion to Esther to keep quiet when she sees him?
3. Why does Esther not want to greet the stranger face to face?
4. Why does the stranger seek to find the man who impregnated Esther?
5. What is the relationship between the Stranger and the Indian attendant? (friends, captives, slaves, etc.)
2. Why does the stranger motion to Esther to keep quiet when she sees him?
3. Why does Esther not want to greet the stranger face to face?
4. Why does the stranger seek to find the man who impregnated Esther?
5. What is the relationship between the Stranger and the Indian attendant? (friends, captives, slaves, etc.)
Reverend Arthur Dimesdale Questions
1. Does the Reverend approach Hester's situation by comforting her, and appealing to her love for God, or does he forcefully insinuate that she is a sinner, and will not go to Heaven?
2. Do you believe that the Reverend will use Hester's baby as leverage, so she will reveal the father's name?
3. If Hesther believes that "[her] child must seek a heavenly Father" rather than her biological father, then why is she so reluctant to revealing who he is to Reverend Dimmesdale?
2. Do you believe that the Reverend will use Hester's baby as leverage, so she will reveal the father's name?
3. If Hesther believes that "[her] child must seek a heavenly Father" rather than her biological father, then why is she so reluctant to revealing who he is to Reverend Dimmesdale?
Wednesday, January 21, 2015
Reverend Arthur Dimmesdale Questions
1.) When Reverend Arthur Dimmesdale is talking about Hester, he 'brought the listeners into one accord of sympathy' (Hawthorne 61). Does this mean that he sympathizes, at least slightly with Hester?
2.) Does Reverend Arthur Dimmesdale know who the father of the child is?
3.) Are Reverend Arthur Dimmesdale and Hester acquaintances or friends? He does not call her a 'poor sinner' instead of using her name like John Wilson did, but he refers to her just by her first name. Is this a sign of them knowing each other?
2.) Does Reverend Arthur Dimmesdale know who the father of the child is?
3.) Are Reverend Arthur Dimmesdale and Hester acquaintances or friends? He does not call her a 'poor sinner' instead of using her name like John Wilson did, but he refers to her just by her first name. Is this a sign of them knowing each other?
Women in Town Discussion Questions
1. Why did Hawthorne make the women in the crowd to be less attractive than Hester who he portrayed as being elegant and beautiful?
2. How do the women feel about Hester and her actions?
3. Why do the women think that Hester’s punishment is not
severe enough and can cause the wives and daughters of the colony to go astray?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)